Grow Up Tag Free

Or Not To Be

In Metablog on April 13, 2008 at 3:25 pm

It seems I have tilted lately towards personal-reflective type posts, and that can get annoying and make me lose my focus and join the ranks of “them bloggers who are female, maintain personal blogs, and think everything is right with the world when they go shopping.” I have always resented that stereotype because female bloggers add as much, if not more, value as their male counterparts and especially so in the Arab blogosphere (we’ll argue over the validity of calling a group of blogs a “blogosphere” later).

This isn’t a post about bloggers and their stereotypes and all that jazz. Nor is it about women and their undeniable contributions. This is a post about my own demons and how they relate to and affect this space I call my blog.

Last night, I had a reading marathon of sorts. I had stopped reading extracurricular books almost since the start of this semester under the excuse that I barely had time to finish class readings and work. That was a lie I told myself to make myself feel better about spending hours chatting online or thinking of my future, which are all good activities, but ones that have consumed me with an appetite lately.

So as I was saying, yesterday I started and completed Amin Maalouf’s In the Name of Identity: Violence and the Need to Belong, which prompted, or re-fueled, a number of questions I had and also answered many I was challenging myself and others with. Maalouf articulated my thoughts for me, clearly and precisely, and that lifted a load off my brain. But, like any good argument, it also left me with other questions.

In the Name of Identity is a book about identity and how it plays a role in our behavior, reception, and perception of other people and of changes in the world. The book looks at things historically and logically (as Maalouf has an affinity with history) and attempts to dissect the current situation of the world, yes –the world, what a big arena!, from that perspective but also with an inevitable touch of evolutionary rhetoric. It does so using a personal tone and it explains the obvious which most of us cannot quite put our fingers on.

I enjoyed reading Maalouf immensely, and I wondered how come I never read my father’s copy of hisThe Crusades Through Arab Eyes. I suppose it was because when I was younger, history was synonymous with things long gone that I should not bother with, events which are both dull and draining to remember, and names of dead people. But not anymore do I think that way.

According to Maalouf, with whom I agree, our current plague as a global village is the holding-on to tribal identities. At the sight of the word “tribal” people will imagine tents and camels and an atmosphere strictly Arab, but that’s not an accurate picture. What he means by tribal is the idea that we must be belong, that we do belong, to one tribe almost exclusively and above all others: religion, nationality, gender, you name it. It is when this “tribe” is most threatened that we resort to classifying ourselves under its flag with vehemence. This classification changes according to the various threats, actual or fictional, that we observe, and it leads us to stress points that were once negligible, and it leads us to close ourselves up. It’s reflex supreme.

Lest this post turn into an analysis of Maalouf’s work, I will stop talking about it here. It has influenced what I am about to say, though: this blog was started as an attempt to fight stereotypes (mainly of veiled women, Arab women, and Arab people and culture). Now I know why it was so. Because when I started this blog, I felt threatened as a veiled, Arab woman and I felt greatly marginalized both in the Arab world or what I received of it, and in other places where I had been where people would either look down at me with disgust and mistrust or with sheer pity. Nobody, not here or there, could pierce through my appearance to know that I liked piercings, fine arts, and modern languages, or that I had severe doubts about what set of beliefs I had which kept secretly yet dramatically changing over time. Nobody bothered, and nobody knew who I was.

That was the thesis of this blog: to show “them” that I can think and even excel at it, use English extremely well, and have discussions with whomever I want about whatever subject. Thus, I thought, I would achieve balance between upper and middle class Jordanians, and between the West and the Arab East, and by that I would have acted as a bridge and resolved conflict within my capacity.

So since that was the driving force behind my entering the blogging scene, and I continue to adhere to the same principles, what new do I bring? Why does the not-so-occasional personal rant sneak in here if this is a strictly serious and mission-oriented space? My ideas have changed, why do I let myself be confused with someone I was and no longer am? How come I can’t express my opinions as bluntly as I shoot them when asked about them in real-life? I mean, my real-life opinions have earned me quite a reputation and a load of problems starting with family and ending with school, so why can’t I risk having that reputation and those problems through this blog? Why not transmit the same issues I worry about and fight over on a daily basis through here? What do I fear?

I don’t know yet. It could be a distant relative suddenly realizing I am someone they know and then telling my parents I am sharing family issues online. It could be an ex-acquaintance realizing I didn’t portray them as perfect and leaving me angry comments. It could be a stalker, old or new, out on the hunt for anything that can be turned into abuse. It could be futile dialog that takes an unpredicted turn in the comments section. It could be anything. I really, and honestly, can’t point it out.

Still, this uneasiness makes me want to stop blogging. If I bring nothing of value and nothing new, unlike others who obviously do since they enjoy a lot more popularity (and I keep my opinions of their contributions to myself), then why bother? If the people like chirpy entertainment junk-food-for-the-brain type things or hardcore extremism, would it matter if a moderate rational tried to sell her stuff? If I can’t affect change like I set out to do, then why sit idly by and watch my blog become filled with little quirky tales about my eccentricities and other trivia? If I do not have a distinct voice amidst the masses, what’s the point except satisfying my own ego? And isn’t that petty?

  1. I read The Crusades Through Arab Eyes. years ago. Good book.

  2. Tololy, you bring a significant contribution to the table, whether ‘issue’ stuff or your personal ranting. I have NEVER gotten the impression your blog was about ego.
    But I do know the fear you speak of.
     
     

  3. Maalof was a real hard critic when I presented an analytical study on the content of Arab Blogs from a peace/war journalism approach at the Oriental Studies department, Stockholm University. He refused to consider blogs a form of journalism.
    However, later in the evening he was soothed after eating genuine deer meat, and we engaged in an open minded discussion about the “Swedo-Arab identity”.
    The last I have heard or seen of him was his debate with Lisa Goldman on CNN, about her visit to Beirut, where he took quite an oppositional view.

    Sorry about irritating you earlier. Really am.

  4. Oj.. my bad, it wasnt Amin Maaluf, it was Professor Ramez Maaluf. I should not comment anymore before reading twice.

  5. *warning half asleep so might irritate upon reading but bear with me*
    on maalouf book, although i haven’t read it but its been pushed on me a few times and i guess its about time to open it up and give it a go since in my heart i think it ignores one main thing regarding identity. its that our sense of belonging to an identity gives us the passion to innovate and create a new one. no identity should be static but belonging to an identity that we don’t desire is the impetus for development and change of that identity in a new one (atleast thats the gist of my counter argument)
    and since the argument started with identity, your uneasiness about being as blunt as you would like to be is the cause of belonging to an identity which you have no longer the heart of belonging to and you are clinging to it due to your want to avoid conflict and it seeps in the form of personal posts that allude to some of them and the avoidance of other issues that even though you admit to halfheartedly but never state them as a matter of fact.
    as for contribution, on the small scale that is jordan, it is visible and let me tell you appreciated… hell its one of a handle few that i actually take people to task in discussions on and if anything i appreciate that on a personal level. alas at a general public level people are more likely to stick to half assed internet junk rather than invest any thought into a discussion or a topic. as for the significance of that to you is that you put ur ideas and offer them to the wolves. usually you end up observing if they get devoured or not and i would like to see you trying to defend them some more :D
     
     
     
     
     
     
     

  6. Hi… To address one of your points, who is to define what is of value? Something ‘new’ is not necessarily of value in itself - and I feel that an important element of blogging is creating community, connecting in unexpected ways, sharing ideas. Sometimes it’s through something ‘trivial’, and sometimes it’s through something more profound - but perhaps we as bloggers can’t predict ourselves the way in which a connection will be made. So please don’t stop :)

  7. identity is a vague word, but if you want to look into it, 1. its how you precieve yourself as in what you means to you which is a story itself and is whats worth spending energy on discovering 2. then how you identify among the people of your community which is seen through culture and history, at the end of the day they are people and from these people who counts are whom you care for and who truly should know you for you (1) and you should work on them knowing you since others are just there and you will never get to fix everyone’s head 3. respectively this community will identify among others and so on, who puts the defining frame relating all those, its you and me and everyone proportionally as it slowly changes through years because it changes on a personal level.

  8. Amongst a sea of useless information and blogs devoid of interesting content, your blog is always refreshing to read and appreciate. I don’t think that what you write is merely trivia. I don’t know if that is any consolation for you, but know that you are probably the only person in the world that thinks that way about your blog! :)
    As for identity, I think that to a large extent we do indeed hold very tight to our “tribes” which essentially result in the vast differences rampant within society, but at the same time I believe that our own personal reservations are also to blame for these divisions. I suppose many of these reservations have religious, social, and political connotations but sometimes these reservations are from deep within ourselves.
     

  9. Toloy,
    am a regular reader of your blog even though i dont leave comments but i always leave smiling :) and believe it or not whenever i feel the need for a good read i just pay u a visit.. so dear do please keep the keyboard running and your space rich with everything and anything.. it is always pleasant to open your box and enjoy the surprise  :)
     
     
     
     
     
     

  10. shoo Tol, btedalla3y 3laina 3shan tshoofy addashe ben7eb ur box :P
    c’mon girl, every work has its ups & downs so don’t let go of yours that easily!
    I’ve learned some things from your posts, I agreed with ones and disagreed with others, some posts showed a little Pride, some showed skills, knowledge, personal thoughts…etc.
    but this is a blog about I believe, regardless what was the main stimulus for you to start this it’s now a part of you, giving it up wont be pleasing nor necessary (at least till I stop reading it J)
    Just kidding Tol, try to get over this phase and keep it up please.

  11. Oh, truly what a coincidence..writing about Maaouf on teh same day! Great Post though, Maalouf and all:) I’m getting this book next, sure seems like a god read!

  12. Isn’t this post purly about ego?
    Don’t get angry, I can totally relate to what you are writing, I used to believe for a while that I don’t need an identity at all. What  for? Being constantly on borders between worlds. ..
     Now, I’ve  realized that every single bit is important, trivia or not.

  13. Oh wow! You definitely have to read my last post: http://diaryofasoom.blogspot.com/2008/04/does-blogging-take-you-away-from-real.html

    Although my initial purpose to start a blog is different from yours, I’ve also been questioning its evolution and wonder whether there’s a purpose for my blog anymore since I feel more inhibited and sensitive to judgement.  I feel like I just can’t talk about what I really want to talk about on my blog and it’s frustrating.
    I love this post and I’m totally relating to it, nevertheless I just have to point out that I am female, a personal blogger, and sometimes “everything is right with the world” when I go shopping…..NO APOLOGIES

All comments are screened for appropriateness. Commenting is a privilege, not a right. Good comments will be cherished, bad comments will be deleted.